Difference between revisions of "Guidelines"

From PDP/Grid Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
Line 4: Line 4:
 
== Definition of project ==
 
== Definition of project ==
  
In the context of these pages, a project is a PDP activity that consumes significant resources.
+
In the context of these pages, a project is a PDP activity that consumes significant resources.
----
+
* for manpower resources, a project is significant if it will consume more than 80 hours.
Resource consumption is significant enough to warrant tracking as a project, whenever the tracking overhead drops below 10%.  Assume for the moment an overhead of 1 hour for the start memo, 2 hours for the quarterly status memo, and 4 fours for the final report.  For a project lasting less than three months in calendar time, the threshold is then 50 hours; for a project lasting more than three months, the threshold is 70 hours.
+
* for financial resources, a project or purchase is significant if it will consume more than 1000 euros.
----
+
 
Hours above are real hours spent working on the project.  These definitions should be evaluated for usefulness as we acquire experience.  The start memo is also relevant to expenses; if we apply the same rule, the threshold is anything costing more than 625 euros (standard figure for personnel 100k / yr = 62,5 euro/hr which is 10% of 625 euros).
+
See below for motivation of these thresholds.
  
 
; [[Rationale]] : Why do these guidelines exist.
 
; [[Rationale]] : Why do these guidelines exist.
Line 14: Line 14:
 
; [[Periodic Report]] : 1-page memo about project progress each quarter.
 
; [[Periodic Report]] : 1-page memo about project progress each quarter.
 
; [[Final Report]] : Memo and optional technical appendices accompanying project completion.
 
; [[Final Report]] : Memo and optional technical appendices accompanying project completion.
 +
 +
 +
== Motivation of thresholds ==
 +
 +
A project as defined here is estimated to cost, at the very least, five hours: one hour to construct the 1-page start memo and four hours to construct the final report.  This overhead should be low compared to the actual work of the project.  Using a figure of 10% as the '''maximum''' allowed overhead for project tracking and reporting, we get 50 hours as a threshold for manpower consumption.
 +
 +
Similarly, the cost of the time consumed motivating a purchase should be small compared to the actual purchase cost.
 +
* a standard employee cost to Nikhef is 100k/yr for 1600 overhead-free hours = 62,5 euros per hour
 +
* cost to construct the 1p memo is 1 hour = 62,5 euros = 10% of 625 euros.
 +
 +
To err on the safe side with project overhead, these thresholds are bumped to the nice round numbers of 80 hours and 1000 euros.  These thresholds should be periodically evaluated for effectiveness.

Revision as of 16:03, 11 November 2015

Note: all guidelines are subject to periodic evaluation for effectiveness.


Definition of project

In the context of these pages, a project is a PDP activity that consumes significant resources.

  • for manpower resources, a project is significant if it will consume more than 80 hours.
  • for financial resources, a project or purchase is significant if it will consume more than 1000 euros.

See below for motivation of these thresholds.

Rationale
Why do these guidelines exist.
1P Memo
1-page memo motivating project start.
Periodic Report
1-page memo about project progress each quarter.
Final Report
Memo and optional technical appendices accompanying project completion.


Motivation of thresholds

A project as defined here is estimated to cost, at the very least, five hours: one hour to construct the 1-page start memo and four hours to construct the final report. This overhead should be low compared to the actual work of the project. Using a figure of 10% as the maximum allowed overhead for project tracking and reporting, we get 50 hours as a threshold for manpower consumption.

Similarly, the cost of the time consumed motivating a purchase should be small compared to the actual purchase cost.

  • a standard employee cost to Nikhef is 100k/yr for 1600 overhead-free hours = 62,5 euros per hour
  • cost to construct the 1p memo is 1 hour = 62,5 euros = 10% of 625 euros.

To err on the safe side with project overhead, these thresholds are bumped to the nice round numbers of 80 hours and 1000 euros. These thresholds should be periodically evaluated for effectiveness.