Security middleware deployment planning

Summary: normally you should install Argus for central authorization and mapping, but a few special cases apply. Alternatively, SCAS may be used.

See if any of the following statements apply.

I would like to do policy management, user mapping and user banning all from one place

The default choice is to set up Argus[1], and configure your resources to use it (see below).

I use dynamic secondary group mappings which require LDAP updates

In this case, you need to use the LDAP enforcement plugin for LCMAPS. This cannot be used in conjunction with Argus; use SCAS as the default alternative.

My cluster is set up to do local mappings to match users to job slots

This is a special case, which can be handled by setting up LCMAPS without a central authorization service (i.e. node-local).

I'm using 3rd party plugins for LCMAPS

We can't say in general if a plugin will or will not work with either Argus or SCAS in this case. You should try Argus first, SCAS next, and node-local setups finally.

I've tried Argus and it didn't work; now what?

Open a support ticket in GGUS[2] for Argus and get it fixed. In the meantime, try to use SCAS as an alternative.

I don't want/need central policy management, mapping or banning

You should set up LCMAPS independently per resource, possibly with a shared NFS gridmapdir to keep consistency between mappings.