Difference between revisions of "Upgrade/RFFoil/WoodsMetal"

From LHCb Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
 
(14 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
Wood's metal is an allay with a low melting point, about 60 degrees C. A lot of information on Woods metal can just be found on WikiPedia:
+
Wood's metal is an alloy with a low melting point, about 60 degrees C. A lot of information on Woods metal can just be found on WikiPedia:
  
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wood%27s_metal
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wood%27s_metal
  
Wood's contains cadmium and lead, and therefore is poisonous. However, there are a variety of alloys with similar low melting point. Not all of these are poisonous, for instance Field's metal. The latter is a lot more expensive, but that's probably not a problem since we don't need a whole lot of it.
+
Wood's metal contains cadmium and lead, and therefore is poisonous. However, there are a variety of alloys with similar low melting point that do not contain cadmium.
  
 
+
A few things that I found so far (September 2014)
 
+
* non-toxic are field's metal (62 C) and cerrolow 136 (58 C)
A few things that I found so far:
+
* cerrosafe (74 C) is said to be specifically suitable for machining: this is probably because on solidification is first shrinks a little and then slowly expands again. after 1 hour it has almost exactly the same size as in the molten state
* non-toxic are field's metal (62 C) and cerrolow 136 *58 C)
 
* cerrosafe (74 C) is said to be specifically suitable for machining: this is probably because on solidification is first shrinks a little and then slowly expands again. after 1 our it has almost exactly the same size as in the molten state
 
 
* cerrobend (basically Wood's metal) expands on solidification by about a factor 1.006
 
* cerrobend (basically Wood's metal) expands on solidification by about a factor 1.006
 
* solid field's metal has a thermal expansion coefficient that is very close to Aluminum (22 x 10^-6)
 
* solid field's metal has a thermal expansion coefficient that is very close to Aluminum (22 x 10^-6)
Line 24: Line 22:
  
 
http://www.rotometals.com/SearchResults.asp?Search=fields+metal
 
http://www.rotometals.com/SearchResults.asp?Search=fields+metal
 +
 +
In the end we have ordered from Lowden Limited 1kg of Fields metal and 1 kg of Cerrolow 136. These are less toxic.
 +
 +
== How to decide on what to use? ==
 +
 +
Cerrolow 136 (58 �C, 8.5 kg/l, 1.7kEuro/liter) is about half the price of Field's metal (62 �C, 7.88 kg/l, 3.4kEuro/liter).
 +
 +
What do we need to look at to decide which one we use?
 +
 +
* shrinkage expansion after solidification: Clow136 skrinks 2x10-4. For a thickness of 2mm, that is less than 1 micron, so probably irrelvant. For Field's metal, we don't know.
 +
* expansion coefficient? Both should be very close to Al (22-23x10^-6/�C).
 +
* melting temperature/conductivity? (how warm could foil become while machining?)
 +
* fluidity: how easily does it flow? does it have sufficient capillary action to make a good film between foil and mold?
 +
* Al affinity: does it stick well to the Al during milling in its solid phase? can we easily get it off again in its liquid phase?
 +
* recoverability: stuff is rather expensive (count 5 liter for final box?). how well can we recover it?
 +
* toxity: Field's metal does not contain lead and less bismuth

Latest revision as of 09:32, 23 October 2014